Give Away the First Stamp: Why Customers Come Back More Often

Picture two customers who walk into your bakery on the same day and sign up for your stamp card. Both need eight more purchases to earn the reward. The only difference: one gets a card with eight empty boxes, and the other gets a ten-box card with two stamps already on it "for signing up." The effort is identical, but the second customer is far more likely to finish. It's called the endowed progress effect, it's been measured with real customers, and using it in your business costs you nothing.
What the endowed progress effect is
The idea is simple: when we feel we've already made progress toward a goal, we try harder to finish it, even if that progress was handed to us. Researchers Joseph C. Nunes and Xavier Drèze named it in 2006 in a study published in the Journal of Consumer Research, "The Endowed Progress Effect: How Artificial Advancement Increases Effort".
What makes it relevant to you is where they tested it: at a car wash, with good old-fashioned stamp cards. They handed out 300 cards to customers. Half needed eight stamps to get a free wash. The other half needed ten, but came with two already stamped. Either way, customers had to pay for eight washes.
The result, as reported in Coglode's summary of the study: over nine months, 19% of customers with the empty eight-stamp card completed it, compared with 34% of those with the ten-stamp card and two free stamps. Almost twice as many customers came back eight times.
Why it works: the goal looks closer
There's another phenomenon behind this, the goal gradient: the closer we see the reward, the faster we go after it. Ran Kivetz, Oleg Urminsky and Yuhuang Zheng confirmed it with a coffee shop's "buy 10 coffees, get 1 free" program. According to the Columbia Business School summary, customers bought coffee more often as they got closer to the free one.
In the same study they also tried giving away stamps: a 12-box card with two "bonus" stamps versus a standard 10-box card. Both required ten coffee purchases, but customers with the 12-box card finished sooner: a median of 10 days versus 15.
What that means at your counter: an empty card looks like a long road you haven't started yet. A card with a couple of stamps looks like something already underway, and it would be a shame to leave it half done.
The catch you can't skip: the gift needs a reason
There's one important condition. As Jonathan Becher explains in his analysis of the study, Nunes and Drèze found that the gifted progress made people more eager to join the program and made it more appealing. But they also found the effect disappeared if no reason was given for that head start.
In other words, it's not enough for the card to show up with two stamps as if by magic. The customer needs to understand that they're a gift and why you're giving them:
- "Here are two welcome stamps for signing up."
- "This week, to celebrate our opening, you start your card with a free stamp."
- "Since you're one of the first to switch to the phone card, here are two on us."
If you tell them at the register while you stamp, the gift comes across as a nice touch from your business, not a trick.
How to use it in your business without giving too much away
The key in both studies is that the real effort doesn't change. It's not about giving the reward sooner; it's about adding as many boxes to the card as stamps you give away. If you currently give the reward at eight stamps, switch to a ten-stamp card and give two when customers sign up. Your margin stays the same and the customer feels they've already started.
Some examples by type of business:
Bakery
The customer who buys a loaf comes in almost every day. With a 12-stamp card (one stamp per purchase) and 2 welcome stamps, the reward is ten purchases away: a loaf, or a pastry for the weekend. They'll have it in a couple of weeks, and they can see progress from day one.
Coffee shop
The study's example fits perfectly here: a 12-box card with 2 free stamps and the thirteenth coffee on the house. You'll find more ideas in our article on the benefits and uses of digital stamp cards for your coffee shop.
Hair salon
Visits are several weeks apart, so a ten-stamp card would take forever. A short one works better: 6 stamps with 1 welcome stamp, and a reward customers will notice, like a deep-conditioning treatment or a discount on their next cut.
Produce shop
Spending varies a lot between someone buying two bananas and someone doing their weekly shop, so stamping by amount spent makes sense: one stamp for every €10, for example. With two free stamps, a new customer can already see they're closer to their reward.
Lunch-menu restaurant
The customer who pops down from the office next door for lunch comes back several times a week. You could give them a 10-meal card with 2 free stamps when they sign up. On the eleventh, dessert and coffee are on you, or the whole meal if the numbers work.
After the reward, the counter resets
The study by Kivetz and his team offered another useful clue. According to the same Columbia summary, after the first reward customers came in less often and then sped up again as they got closer to the second.
That dip after redeeming is the tricky moment. A few ideas to bridge it:
- Stamp the purchase on redemption day too. If a customer gets their free coffee and also orders a croissant, they should leave with their new card already started.
- Give them a bigger goal. With card tiers, completing a card isn't the end: it's a step toward the next tier. If you're interested, here's how to motivate loyal customers with Bronze, Silver and Gold tiers.
- Remind them what they've got. A customer with five stamps who hasn't been in for three weeks might just need a heads-up that their stamps are about to expire, or a "we haven't seen you in a while" message.
What to avoid
- Giving away stamps without explaining why. As we've seen, without a reason the effect is lost.
- Requiring fewer purchases instead of changing how the card is presented. If you give two stamps without adding boxes, you're not applying the effect: you're offering a discount.
- Changing the rules for people who already have a card. If you make the card longer, do it only for new customers, or honor the stamps everyone else already has.
How Befoo helps
With Befoo, each business has its own digital stamp card, with its own logo and colors. You decide how many stamps it has, what the reward is and how stamps are earned: per purchase, by amount spent or per item. Customers create a free account and carry their Befoo QR code on their phone, including in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet. Your staff stamp using their own phones by scanning that QR code. So a welcome stamp goes on just like any other, in a couple of seconds.
For the endowed progress effect to work, customers need to see their progress, and that's what the card on their phone is for. Every stamp comes with an automatic notification, they know how many they need for the reward, and they get another notification when their stamps are about to expire. If you use card tiers (on the Premium plan), every completed card brings the customer closer to the next tier, which has its own reward. Befoo also asks for Google reviews at the right moment, for example when a customer redeems a reward. It never offers anything in return, and it asks every customer, not just the happy ones.
See everything included in the loyalty program for small businesses and check the pricing. There's a free plan, with unlimited customers and one location, so you can try it for yourself: create your free stamp card and start giving away that first stamp this week.


